This book could have been cut down 200 pages. I know, I'm always the first one to complain if the author doesn't give enough back story to let you know what's going on, but in this case less would have been acceptable. For some reason the author seemed think that we needed to know all about the childhood and relationship woes of both main characters: Meredith and Roberta. Pages and pages full. Even knowing their personal history I still didn't care much for them. Just not very likable personalities.
This little book packs a punch! Creepy, dark and very disturbing. I haven't read a "horror" story this good in awhile.
Author Kate Summerscale seems to have done quite a bit of research for this book. Lots of famous and not so famous names seem to be coming out of the woodwork. She does give you an inside glimpse of Victorian medical practices and cures of the time (an boy they had some pretty strange ideas back then). Makes me oh so glad that medicine and psychology have come a long ways. The problem is her writing style is so boring and wordy it makes me not care enough to go to GOOGLE and see if any of it could be true.
I agree with the other reviewers its a whole lot like Alice in Wonderland meets the Wizard of Oz. This is my second novel that I've read by Valente, and I think she is an exceptional writer. As much as I like Fairytales, I always find surreal imagery tiring for my poor brain. I wouldn't recommend this book for young children, tweens an adults would probably enjoy it more. It is at times a bit morbid, and on the dark side, but it does have a great ending.
A definitely disturbing and shocking read and yet it felt like the story was lacking any real depth. I believe there could have been so much more explored here, for instance Fran and Lizzie's relationship. The two women lived together for years and shared the same man and yet not much about Fran is revealed. The three other women slaves that Lizzie befriends at the Tawawa house seem more interesting then her, "the lead character" and yet we get no back story on them as well. The ending was dribble as far as I am concerned. Not a bad read, but a not very satisfying one either.
I like weird and unusual stories, and this book fits right in that category. Author Shawn Hopkins has rolled some of my favorites together (ancient Egyptian mythology, the biblical nephilim, and the mysterious Bermuda Triangle) and created at first glance a rather interesting tale. It also looks as if he took the time to do some research into these rather enigmatic subjects.
What a fun, fun read! It's clever, smart, techy and oh, soo---cool!
My basic issue with this book was, it was to rushed. Events were taking place to quickly and not being well defined. Then there were these huge time gaps with unaccountable time and then suddenly something would happen. I felt, I was being too hurried along through the story.
I listened to this on audio, it was only two and a half hours long. Narrated by the author himself George Carlin.
I love Victorian settings! Harwood does a superb job of creating a creepy, gothic atmosphere, and I'm also a fan of literary style of writing. I enjoyed the mystery up until the ending was revealed, and then I was a bit disappointed. A good read never the less.
Seems to be a highly raved about book, I thought it was dreadful.
Not a bad read but I was hoping for more out of it. The protagonist,"Annie" was just a bit to sarcastic for my taste. I understand she's been the victim of a heinous crime but her snarky tone with an almost sense of black humor thrown in seemed to down play what should have been absolute horror. And the ending? Well lets just say I thought it was a little far fetched.
Fantastic read!